SWOT vs SOAR: Choosing the Right Tool

Navigating the complexities of strategic planning can be challenging, especially when it comes to choosing the right tools to guide decision-making. Over the years, I’ve worked with both SWOT and SOAR analyses, each serving a unique purpose depending on the organization’s goals and timeframe. Let’s compare these two approaches.

SWOT Analysis: Addressing Immediate Challenges and Short-Term Planning

SWOT Analysis—Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats—is ideal for short-term projects and immediate challenges. Its power lies in helping teams conduct a thorough environmental scan, providing insight into internal strengths and weaknesses alongside external opportunities and threats.

For example, when we’re working on issues management strategies, SWOT analysis is my go-to. It’s a straightforward tool for supporting environmental scans, identifying immediate opportunities, and threats. When we worked on the CN Indigenous Advisory Council resignation project, a SWOT analysis helped us analyze the history of the issue, the present situation, our communication opportunities, and the potential threats that would get in the way of success.

SOAR Analysis: Inspiring Transformation and Long-Term Vision           

In contrast, SOAR Analysis—Strengths, Opportunities, Aspirations, and Results—is a forward-looking approach ideal for long-term strategic planning. The tone of SOAR is aspirational, emphasizing the organization’s aims and desired outcomes. It is my choice for long-term plans that require a focus on growth, engagement and, most importantly, results.

For instance, when working with the Saskatchewan First Nations Water Association, we used a SOAR analysis to develop their first three-year rolling strategic plan. This method was perfect for crafting a shared vision that everyone could align with, ensuring that all interest holders were engaged in shaping a results-focused, long-term plan.

SWOT vs. SOAR: How to Choose the Right Tool for Your Project

 To decide between SWOT and SOAR, consider:

• Are you addressing immediate challenges or planning long-term?
• Do you need to evaluate internal factors or focus on aspirations?
• Are you understanding the current environment or creating a future plan?
• Is inspiration for the team a goal, or do you need a critical assessment?
• Are measurable, future-oriented results important?

Get in Touch: Strategic Planning and Communication Advisory

Whether you’re facing urgent issues or planning for transformation, we’re here to help with strategic planning and communication work.